My previous two blog posts were about the disputed termination of former Dickinson Street Maintenance manager David Armendariz and his hearing with the Civil Service Commission. In a second article by the Dickinson Press from December 12 about the deliberation and finding of the Civil Service Commission, it concluded that there was nothing wrong with the City of Dickinson’s termination of David Armendariz.
This finding of the Civil Service Commission made me wonder, would the Civil Service Commission ever disagree with what the City of Dickinson does? Who are the members of the Civil Service Commission, and how are they appointed?
I have seen many times in my life, where an individual has the mistaken belief that a company or an organization will do what is right, be a fair arbiter of fact, adhere to some kind of ethics, or do what they said they were going to do. Some companies and organizations have a methodology of stating and appearing that they will act in good faith, but proceed to delay, waste time with formality and processes, dilute facts, disregard evidence, introduce doubt, create ambiguity, with the intention of finding in the end, whatever suited their interests.
To give an example, I have read more than several newspaper articles where an individual claimed that an Electric Company, Water Company, or Gas Company removed all of the money from the individual’s bank account through an auto-pay billing or debit card transaction, due to a supposed $10,000 charge. Here is how Electric Companies, Water Companies, and Gas Companies handle this type of dispute by a customer:
Dear Mr. Smith,
We have investigated the matter concerning your belief that you were incorrectly charged for services. We have conducted a review of all pertinent information and examined our records. We can find no error in billing on our part, and the charges are correct.
Please let us know if we can be of further assistance.
Asshole at the Electric Company
The reason that I have read more than several of these stories in the newspaper, is because the only way that these individuals were able to get their money back, was by going to a television station or newspaper and getting a reporter to go to the Electric Company, Water Company, or Gas Company and begin investigating for their news story. At that time, when the Electric Company, Water Company, or Gas Company management learned that everything was going to be exposed, which might lead to them losing their job, they always gave the money back and issued the following statement:
“There has been a misunderstanding, which has now been addressed and resolved with Mr. Smith.”
I could go on with more stories about people mistakenly believing that a company or an organization was going to be a fair arbiter of fact, but I won’t. The point that I want to make is this, I don’t know why any individual in Dickinson would think that they were going to get anywhere with the Civil Service Commission based on the history of outcomes. Why even bother.
One way that the Civil Service Commission benefits the City of Dickinson, is that individuals never get anywhere, their claims are denied. Not only are the individual’s claims denied, but the City of Dickinson doesn’t even have to pay an attorney to accomplish this.
From now on, if any employee of the City of Dickinson feels like they were unjustly or unfairly treated, hire an attorney, sue the City of Dickinson. Don’t even waste your time going to the Civil Service Commission.
Once the City of Dickinson has to litigate again, and again, and again, then you might start to see some real change in personnel and practices with the City of Dickinson.